Wotancraft Commander Review

By August 20, 2015Blog, Review, User Report

Wotancraft Commander Review

Introduction

I’ve been sitting on the new Wotancraft Commander for a while now so I’m relieved to finally get this review posted.

Whilst the Commander is the latest addition to Wotancraft’s “City Explorer” line up, it’s backpack styling highlights it as a clear departure from the more traditional single shoulder strap bags in the range.

With that in mind I felt the need to do something a little different with it in order to properly test it, you can see and read more on that later in the review.

 So, lets take a thorough look at the Wotancraft Commander!! 

Specification

Courtesy of Wotancraft

Package Contents Include

  • City Explorer “Commander” Backpack 
  • Lightweight shock-resistant insert for camera & lenses 
  • 1no Microfiber dividers (no cap) 
  • 2no Microfiber dividers (with cap)
  • 1no T-shaped divider 
  • Cotton dustproof bag with WOTANCRAFT Chinese insignia 
  • “REMOVE BEFORE ADVENTURE” military ordnance tag keychain 

 

Outer Bag Materials

  • Vegetable tanned cowhide leather
  • Waterproof W.A.L canvas
  • High-strength metal hardware
  • High-density foam padding (shock-resistant insert)
  • Bronze YKK Zippers (with rustproof coating)

Specs

  • Size (exterior): 17(width)x 33(depth)x 44(height) cm
  • Size (interior) Top Insert: 11(width)x 23(depth)x 19(height) cm
  • Size (interior) Bottom Compartment: 15(width)x 28.5(depth)x 24(height) cm
  • Shoulder Straps: adjustable between 60~87 cm
  • Weight with Insert: 2.6 kg

The Outer Bag

The Wotancraft Commander is my first up close and personal look at their latest outer material specification and I have to say it’s very, very impressive. The W.A.L Canvas, as it’s so named is water repellant, abrasion resistant and lightweight but how does it compare to the previous material I liked so much?

Firstly, as you’d perhaps expect the W.A.L canvas does have a very similar appearance to the original Waxed Canvas, this is great news to me as the visual aesthetic of these bags was always a significant factor in my appreciation of them! I know we’re often told that looks aren’t everything but when talking camera bags, looks really do matter…..

From a few meters away you’d struggle to see any discernible difference, on closer inspection the new W.A.L Canvas is certainly more matte, the previous waxed finish having a slight satin look. I was definitely a fan of the old waxed finish but If pushed now I’d say I prefer the visual appearance of the W.A.L canvas.

Next, the water resistance, I’ve used my Wotancraft bags in some fairly inclement weather it has to be said. Water would slip off the old waxed finish no problem so it was very reassuring to see the water repellant properties of the W.A.L canvas in action and equally pleasing to see it stand up to the weather without issue.

Wotancraft Commander Review Front 1

The “Vintage Gray” canvas and vegetable tanned cowhide leather is a tasteful combination, the W.A.L canvas has an almost chameleon type ability to change tone, adopting subtle purple and even brown tones in various lights

Wotancraft Commander Review Back 2

For me, there was one aspect of the old waxed canvas that was a real stand out positive, I mentioned it in my previous review of the Wotancraft City Explorer Avenger and it relates to durability.

I’ve carried these bags around the world and all over New Zealand, it’s fair to say I have respected them but I certainly haven’t nursed them. Wherever I’ve been, whatever I have been doing, whichever Wotancraft bag I’ve had with me would always look as good as new when I returned, this was down to the durability of the waxed canvas!!

The W.A.L canvas would certainly have it’s work cut out equalling that kind of durability and that was certainly one of the reasons I wanted to put the bag through it’s paces somewhere a little more testing. You can see my field test of the Wontancraft Commander later in this post and read my ultimate verdict on durability.

“This camera bag is too light” said no photographer ever!!!!

In truth, I never had an issue with the weight of the old waxed canvas, it gave unrivalled durability and performance, in turn I accepted that it wasn’t the lightest material known to man. That said, this is most definitely one aspect of the W.A.L canvas that undoubtably improves on the previous material and I suspect one of the overriding factors in the decision to switch materials.

In terms of the Wotancraft Commander and the City Explorer range in general two things have shaved considerable weight off the bags, one is the W.A.L canvas, the other is the omission of the Water Proof Insert, more on that shortly.

Wotancraft Commander Review Side 4

Well positioned pockets and storage along with ample “D” rings for additional flexibility.

Wotancraft Commander Review Side 3

Wotancraft Commander Review 5

Utilising the cowhide for the bottom of the Commander is a nice touch, it really adds another level of protection.

Wotancraft Commander Review 6

Handily placed zip pocket in the cover flap.

Wotancraft Commander Review 7

Whenever I see a new Wotancraft bag I’m always immediately struck by the resounding quality and attention to detail, this bag is no different in that respect. Because it’s handmade and not mass produced there is always the overriding feeling of uniqueness which I absolutely love.

In the 3 years that I’ve been reviewing Wotancraft bags I think they have really established themselves as a brand whose products and service really are worthy of carrying some of your most prized possessions. It’s very apparent to me that these are bags made by photographers, for photographers.  

The Wotancraft Commander retails at US$699 plus delivery which will vary depending on your geographical location and selected delivery method. I realise thats not exactly small change, this is however a bag that’s going to last you a considerable amount of time.

Wotancraft Commander Review 26

The Inner Bag

Wotancraft Commander Review 8

Attention to detail – Stitched in magnetic retainers allow you to expose less or more of the bag contents dependant on your needs.

Wotancraft Commander Review 9

The Wotancraft Commander is essentially split in to two main compartments, the top compartment holds the removable, lightweight shock resistant insert complete with adjustable micro fibre dividers. In turn, the bottom has a adjustable/removable micro fibre “T” divider.  It’s worth noting that the dividing zipper flap that separates top compartment from bottom can be opened up to create one large interior space if your needs require.

As I mentioned a little earlier in the review the waterproof insert that’s currently offered as an option with the Ranger, Avenger and Scout will also be offered as an optional extra on the Commander at some point in the near future. That’s great news because whilst I understand and agree with the decision to omit it as standard, the Commander strikes me as the bag most likely to see the kind of action that would necessitate a waterproof insert.

Moving on, the entire internal arrangement of the Commander is very flexible and would suit a variety of photographers needs. Removal of the lightweight shock resistant insert reveals another internal pocket.

If you specifically want to see how the Commander would work for a DSLR type setup you’ll get a great idea by visiting the Wotancraft Commander page – HERE.

I see the DSLR type setup above as a fairly mainstream use for a backpack like the Commander, so in an effort to highlight a little more of its flexibility and to be slightly less conventional I’ve focused on using the bag in ways that suit my particular equipment and shooting habits.

Wotancraft Commander Review 23

Above – “T” divider removed, creating one space in the bottom compartment of the backpack.

Wotancraft Commander Review 22

Wotancraft Commander Review 21

Above – “T” divider in place, creating three separate spaces in the bottom compartment of the backpack.

Functionality

Taking a look at the Wotancraft Commander when it first arrived I gave some serious thought to how I might utilise it most effectively. I ultimately decided to focus a little more on the backpack aspect of the bag, resisted the urge to fill it with gear and instead decided to treat it as a daypack.

It struck me that as I could fit adequate camera equipment in the top compartment and enough provisions, waterproofs etc in the bottom that the bag was perfect for long days out in remote locations.

Over the shoulder bags are great for most things but once you start to be a bit more adventurous in terms of your physical actions and environment they can soon become troublesome, the Commander backpack solved that issue and left me with two free hands all of the time.

Wotancraft Commander Review 10

The Commander can also accommodate your laptop, the zip opening is a whopping 39cm. My 13″ Macbook Pro in it’s Incipio case fit’s in with an abundance of space to spare. Indeed, I even fitted in my ancient 15″ Macbook Pro (36cm x 24.5cm x 2.5cm) with room to spare. 

Robust and well positioned padding will protect both your back and the laptop.

Wotancraft Commander Review 11

Wotancraft Commander Review 13

The strap length is adjustable between 60cm and 87cm, offering plenty of scope for most peoples needs.

Wotancraft Commander Review 15

Handy, easy access external pockets. 

Wotancraft Commander Review 14

High quality & attention to detail.

Wotancraft Commander Review 16

Remember – “Believe what works” 

Capacity

The Pro DSLR configuration below – Courtest of Wotancraft. I’ve also added a couple of additional configurations that utilise the top compartment only. Clearly there is more room in the bag, these are workable configurations that avoid the need to stack and diminish useability.

  • Pro SLR x2, lens x4-5, Pro Flash x1, accessories (Top & Bottom Compartments)
  • Leica Rangefinder x 2, Lenses x 2-4, accessories (Top Compartment Only)
  • Leica Rangefinder x 1, Lenses x2, Rolleiflex 2.8GX, accessories (Top Compartment Only)

Wotancraft Commander Review 17

In addition to the camera configurations above the bag is also capable of holding various accessories as indicated below. 

Wotancraft Commander Review 19

Wotancraft Commander Review 18

Wotancraft Commander Review 20

Tongariro National Park – “Field Test”

So, given that I’d made the decision to focus on the Commander as a backpack/daypack what better way to put it through its paces than to take it to Tongariro National Park.

I spent several long days in the park doing various walks, I must be in a small minority of people that have walked half way in to the Togariro Crossing and then turned around and come back out, the reason for that? Well I’d promised my wife and friends we’d do it together, didn’t want to get home and say I’d done it alone……

Wotancraft Commander 1

I don’t often carry a tripod and whilst the 190XPROB is relatively small it’s possible to get smaller and lighter options. 

I used the Commander’s tripod straps horizontally with my Manfrotto 190XPROB & 498RC2 ball head, it was totally fine as I was for the most part in wide open spaces.

If you were concerned about any potential tripod overhang then you could try the following as an “unofficial” work around – 

It seems to me that one or two legs of the Tripod can be inserted in to the large pocket and it can be carried vertically and secured via the two “D” rings with some cord, it works fine and would definitely make things easier in more crowded spaces. A very minor point but maybe theres some potential for a small modification here?

Wotancraft Commander 6

You’ve got to love the great outdoors!! 

Wotancraft Commander 5

Wotancraft Commander 4

Wotancraft Commander 3

Wotancraft Commander 2

I wore the Commander backpack for three consecutive days, I should add that these were quite long days, in addition I undoubtably had more weight in the pack than most people would probably carry. The weather was fine so I only had a t-shirt on. The leather straps were rubbing on my shoulders a little by the end. To be fair I think after that amount of time any bag would be feeling a little uncomfortable, still I wonder if it is feasible to add some padding to part of those in the same way you see on a regular strap, food for thought. UPDATE – Since reporting these findings back to Wotancraft the Commander now ships with a pair of detachable pressure-alleviation shoulder pads. These are made of soft microfiber exterior and cushion padding normally used for shoes. 

I have to applaud Wotancraft’s willingness to adapt to constructive feedback and as ever they are swift to implement potential improvements.

Wotancraft Commander 8

Wotancraft Commander 7

Wotancraft Commander 10

Wotancraft Commander 12

Wotancraft Commander 13

Back to the issue of durability and what for me was the big question. Does the new W.A.L canvas match up to the excellent durability of the previously used waxed canvas?

Well looking very closely at the Wotancraft Commander after returning form my trip I’d have to conclude wholeheartedly that indeed it does! To be frank, I could put this Commander back in the cotton dustproof bag it ships in and tell you it’s new, you’d have no reason to doubt it. 

In essence the W.A.L canvas has all the benefits of the waxed canvas but with one very major advantage, it got considerably lighter, that’s a real result!! 

Wotancraft Commander 14

Wotancraft Commander 15

Wotancraft Commander 16

Wotancraft Commander 17

Wotancraft Commander 21

If your photography takes you off the beaten track, maybe this is the backpack for you, if your photography takes you places where it’s not always possible to stop at a cafe for lunch then once again, seriously consider this backpack. If your in the city and just want to be a little bit more self sufficient, maybe carry some provisions a change of clothes, some waterproofs and your camera gear in one stylish backpack, then look no further than the Wotancraft Commander.

Wotancraft Commander 20

Wotancraft Commander 19

Wotancraft Commander 18

Summary

So, an interesting “bag” and I have to say a little bit of an eye opener for me, I’d probably have been a touch dismissive of this design of bag a few weeks ago, certainly for my needs. Now having used the Commander extensively I can really see and appreciate it’s versatility.

I’m pleased to see Wotancraft doing something a little different, I think it’s fair to say that the market for these backpacks is probably more niche than your regular shoulder bag but that hasn’t stopped them trying to cater for the specific needs of photographers, I applaud that approach.

What’s more Wotancraft don’t just make a great end product they actually back it up with fantastic customer service, these people actually care about our opinions and I know that feedback is always welcome. I guess the search for excellence never ends.

Don’t forget Wotancraft also stand behind their products offering a 3-year free repair guarantee, given intended usage of the product (International shipping fee for repairs paid by sender), that’s pretty impressive too.

All in all another very impressive offering from Wotancraft and ultimately a very fine bag, recommended.

As always I’m happy to answer questions and try out gear configurations for fit (If I have it).

Cheers, Jason.

Wotancraft Camera Bags

View the complete range 

HERE

16 Comments

  • jaydee77 says:

    Nice review and beautiful bag indeed!
    Do you have Wotancraft City Explorer messenger?
    I am looking for a camera bag that has reasonable size for one mirrorless camera and some edc stuff.
    It’ll be great if you can review that bag!

    • janrzm says:

      Thanks.

      Yes I do have the Messenger, although it’s not in the latest material. If there’s anything specific you need to know about it I’ll do my best to help.

      Cheers, Jason.

      • jaydee77 says:

        No I don’t have something specific to know, just a general interest. How big, reliable, comfortable this bag is.
        Is this big leather flap handy and practical? It looks too wide for this bag on official photos.
        Is this main leather fastener reliable?

        • janrzm says:

          In terms of size I’d say it’s suitable for Macro 4/3 or mirrorless system, something like the Sony A7 and a couple of lenses. Reliability and quality of these bags is absolutely second to none, I have no reservations in saying that.

          Regarding comfort I personally find it to be in line with all the other City Explorer bags, great strap, no discomfort on the hip. I fully understand your comment about the leather flap, I’d say it’s very subjective in terms of it’s visual appearance and functionality, if you’re frequently in and out of the bag then in my opinion it needs to be folded back against the leg, this may not work for everyone.

  • John Lockwood says:

    Great images and the most thorough review of a camera bag I’ve ever read Jason. You certainly have an abundance of natural beauty to capture in NZ, and this bespoke bag just adds to the environment.

    • janrzm says:

      Thanks John, appreciate that.

      We’re definitely spoilt here, 10 mins drive to the stunning beach at Mt Maunganui and a couple of hours to the volcano’s and skiing….

  • Hi Jason,

    I hate you…
    I am definitively a fan of Wotancraft. I have 2 Rangers (wax fab and wav fab) and then I bought the Ryker Black for city short photo trip.
    Even if I have been very tempted by the Commander since they introduce it, I wanted to be reasonnable and wait, and wait, and wait…
    What did you do with your review???? Now I guess that I will call the Wotancraft Team soon…
    By the way, more than a Wotancraft bag, you buy a fantastic customer service with a real kindness and strong attention. They are GREAT GUYS there!!!
    I am using my Ranger EVERY day to go to work, as I always have 1 camera withe me ( or Sony Nex7 or Fuji X100T ). I should say that after several months, my bag looks even nicer than new (you are right when you compare the Ranger to an old pair of 501 Levis).
    For the Ryker, it is more a “Metro” style bag. But a fantastic quality and a great pleasure to carry with a range finder plus some lenses and accessories, and even an iPad Air inside. I really like to use it as well.
    Thank you Jason for your reviews ‘-)
    Claude ( Alex Emmathom )

    • janrzm says:

      Hey Claude,

      That made me laugh.

      I’m pleased you found the review helpful and I apologise for spending your money for you!! 🙂

      It’s great to hear over peoples experiences with Wotancraft products and service, they are pretty special.

      Cheers, Jason.

  • Darrin says:

    Hi Jason, another cracking review.

  • Rodney Allen says:

    Hi Jason

    Impressive review.
    Your photos tell a story on there own.
    Took the same model tripod to the top of Mt Ngauruhoe, metal version but realised afterwards the carbon fibre version was a lot lighter and I take that on all my tramps now.

    Cheers

    Rodney

  • Harris Saltzburg says:

    Hello Jason! As per usual, excellent review and even better images! I can also attest to the incredible quality associated with Wotancraft bags. I utilize the Avenger (with the new exterior material) with the Waterproof insert. It is like a traveling safe for our beloved equipment, providing a particular sense of security in extremely foul weather. Incredibly durable and it readily accommodates my MacBook Pro 13. I have an old Fogg bag that I truly love, but have always been concerned that it doesn’t really seal against the elements. Although the Wotancraft is a far larger, I can easily carry my film and digital M bodies with lenses. Problem is, the larger the bag, the more we carry, the heavier the load! Cue my smiling children!

  • […] bag range, it’s in the daypack style so I guess you’d say it’s the cousin of the Wotancraft Commander that I reviewed in  August […]

  • Tim Conte says:

    Whoa! This has to be one of the best reviews I’ve seen on any camera bag. Your images are beautiful!

    I have been looking at Wotancraft for some time, but every time I see one in person I can’t help but feel that the materials and workmanship are subpar. How do you compare Wotancraft to say Fogg or Hawkesmill? I have this bag https://hawkesmill.com/product/small-jermyn-street-camera-bag and the build quality is incredible!

    But I want a camera backpack and Hawkesmill doesn’t make one yet.

    Any input would be much appreciated!

    Thanks!
    Tim

    • janrzm says:

      Hey Tim.

      Thanks!! I’ve not seen a Hawkesmill bag in the flesh so to speak, however I look through the link and close up images you sent me and I don’t see anything on there thats superior to my Wotancraft Ryker for instance. I guess we all see things slightly differently. I’d say this, if I was buying a backpack I’d let myself be slightly more relaxed around the aesthetic, the backpacks may not be as “smart” as the Hawkesmill bag but the quality is exemplary as is the functionality. Both the Commander and the Shadow Warrior would do a job for you I’m sure, my preference is the slightly smaller Shadow Warrior – HERE

Leave a Reply